Book Review: Anti-Fascist Economics

German economist Isabella Weber first came to prominence when diagnosing the post-Covid inflation shock as being driven to a large extent by what she called “seller’s inflation”. We call it price gouging, and its prevalence was undeniable. Her policy prescriptions raised the ire of many a mainstream economist for whom interventions like price controls are anathema.

*** A version of this book review was first published in The Irish Times on 14 November 2026 ***

Based in the US, Weber is originally from Nuremberg, the spiritual home of Nazi Germany. She is motivated both by the dark history of her hometown and what she sees as the fascist turn in her adopted home, personified by twice-elected President Trump. Just as hyper-inflation in Weimar Germany ushered in National Socialism the price of eggs, and everything else, was a contributing factor in Trump’s re-election in 2024.

To state the obvious, however, America in the 2020s is a far cry from Germany in the 1930s and the parallels should not be overstated. In some ways the framing of the book as an economic policy response to ward off the rise of fascism does the arguments within it a disservice. It will certainly appeal to those who equate Trump with Hitler, but it risks falling flat with the many who are disgusted by Trump but don’t think the fascist label applies. In fact, the economic analysis and policy responses set out in the book are of relevance far beyond the far left. Recent cuts to excise on fuels in Ireland are a prime example of a mainstream government taking steps to make daily essentials more affordable and thereby neutralise far right agitation.

In Anti-Fascist Economics Weber takes aim at the neoliberal economic model. Inverting the logic of Hayek’s Road to Serfdom, she lays the blame for the supposed return of totalitarianism at the feet of a market – or profit – fundamentalism that has given rise to a new oligarchy and hollowed out public services. She argues that austerity policies, economic insecurity for the masses and surging prices of everyday essentials create the conditions for far right actors to exploit, subordinating markets to an authoritarian national project.

Leaning on Karl Polanyi’s arguments in The Great Transformation, Weber argues that a societal response to the excesses of neoliberalism is inevitable. A fascist turn is one plausible path, but a more democratic and inclusive alternative is infinitely preferable. To this end she was a leading advocate for strategic price controls to contain the post-Covid inflation shock. For having the temerity to advocate for policy responses that have fallen out of fashion since the 1970s she was pilloried in the public square. As she points out, however, many governments did introduce measures aimed at controlling prices, they just weren’t called price controls.

As energy prices surged following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine European countries moved to cap household bills, tax windfall profits, subsidise energy and alter wholesale-market rules. These are price controls by another name. In this case, direct intervention was deemed possible, and politically necessary. Other such measures can include negotiated agreements, anti-gouging rules, subsidies tied to conditions, rationing, public procurement, public options, anti-monopoly measures and maintaining buffer stocks.

The author cites other recent examples of governments acting to contain rising prices of essentials. In Mexico, Andrés Manuel López Obrador’s government negotiated an affordable basket of basic goods with retailers and producers, publicly monitored prices, supported small farmers through minimum prices, built up reserves and put a lid on fuel and electricity costs.

In Spain, Pedro Sánchez’s government response to the energy price shock included capping gas prices for electricity generation, capturing windfall gains, limiting rent increases, reducing public-transport costs and removing tax from essential foods while investing heavily in renewable energy. Inflation fell faster in Spain than in many European countries; electricity prices are sustainably lower and the far-right Vox lost ground in the 2023 election.

In New York, Mayor Zohran Mamdani won election on an affordability platform of rent freezes, public supermarkets, free buses and free childcare. Learning from the implementation of these pledges and policy experimentation elsewhere can inform measures in other jurisdictions. By contrast, the planned 15% average increase in Irish public transport fares from January goes in the opposite direction.

For sure, governments need to be careful when they reach for the price control lever. They need to be selective, well-designed, closely monitored and paired with measures to ensure adequate supply so as to avoid shortages. They should be short term measures that can help buy time for investment and structural reforms to bear fruit.

In the book’s concluding chapter Weber argues that steps are needed to ensure universal access to those goods essential for bodily integrity or social participation: food, water, energy, housing, transport, communications and care. Public provision in housing and care is necessary, for example, where profit-driven supply persistently fails. Weber’s analysis is cogent. Her preferred policy proposals are characteristically bold. Anti-fascist Economics is a worthy contribution to the debate around economic policy at a time when affordability challenges are pervasive and the rise of far right shows little sign of abating. The most important lesson for economic policymakers is that thinking outside the mainstream box is sometimes necessary to ensure the longevity and democratic legitimacy of the economic and political systems alike.

Leave a Reply